
Photo courtesy of L.L. Kirchner
At first glance, The Critic: A Steel City Mystery by L.L. Kirchner looks like a straightforward mystery about the attempted ricin poisoning of Pittsburgh’s most notorious theater critic. It isn’t. The crime is really just the spark that sets off a much more interesting story about trauma, memory, reputation, and how fast the public decides someone’s guilty.
Jessica, the main character, ends up in the middle of the investigation for the usual reasons — motive, opportunity — but mostly because her past makes her the perfect suspect.
Years earlier she discovered her father’s suicide, and she’s been in and out of psychiatric care ever since. She can’t fully trust her own memory, and neither can the police, the reporters, or the neighbors. Kirchner isn’t all that interested in “who did it.” She’s more interested in how easily suspicion hardens into accepted fact.
That’s where the book really works. Almost every character is driven by something recognizable — ambition, fear, resentment, old grudges — and Kirchner has a sharp eye for how those motives play out. The overlapping worlds of journalism, theater, and law enforcement become a study in reputation. Once people start calling Jessica “The Mail Murderess,” the nickname sticks, facts be damned.
[Read more below]
Arts All Around!
The Gabber Newspaper covers live theater and art across South Pinellas. And, when we find something worth the drive, we cover art in the Tampa Bay and Sarasota areas.
A Psychological Suspense Story
If you’re looking for a classic puzzle-box mystery, you may be disappointed. The novel spends less time on clever clues and more time on what it feels like to be accused, and on the family secrets that refuse to stay buried. By the middle of the book the question has shifted from solving a crime to understanding the emotional mess that got everyone here in the first place.
I’ll be honest: it took me a while to settle in. There’s a big cast and a lot of tangled relationships, and I didn’t fully lock onto the story until I was pretty far along. Once I found its rhythm, though, I could see what Kirchner was after. She didn’t write a conventional mystery. She wrote a thoughtful psychological suspense novel about how memory, trauma, and public judgment can be just as poisonous as anything that comes in the mail.
In the end, The Critic grew on me. It upended some of my expectations, and while it wasn’t the book I thought I was picking up, it turned out to be a solid exploration of the stories we tell about other people, and the ones we tell about ourselves.
Keep Your Community Local: Donate Now To Support Us
Donate now to support The Gabber Newspaper. The owners of the paper take no income from the paper. Every penny donated helps keep your community news hyperlocal. And everyone who earns their living working at The Gabber Newspaper lives in Gulfport and St. Petersburg. Most of our freelancers live here, too. We support our community; please support us.
The Gabber Newspaper? Yeah, We Go There.
Did you know: In 1968, our founder, George Brann, started The Gabber Newspaper, then called the Gulfport Gabber, to hold Gulfport City Council accountable. Read more of our city council coverage, and learn about our policies on reporting, fact-checking, and funding.
Get all your Gulfport and Tampa Bay beaches news and things to do at thegabber.com.


